Posts Tagged ‘SHOVEL READINESS’

Low Stimulus Bids Could Be Dangerous, Warns Construction Expert

Wednesday, May 6th, 2009

construction

When the 2,000th stimulus project was approved last month, the White House was touting the fact that bids from contractors were coming in well below expectations — 15 to 20 percent below on average, and 30 percent or more in some places.

But this kind of steep discount is not necessarily good news, cautions an expert on the construction industry.

“When bids are coming in 25 or 30 percent under a reasonable estimate, one of two things is going to happen,” says construction lawyer Barry Lepatner. “Either the contractor completes the work at prevailing wages and accepts a substantial loss, or the company runs out of money part way through.”

Neither outcome is desireable, he says, but the latter would be especially disruptive. “When the contractor has lost so much that they can’t go on, the government doesn’t have a way to give them more money.” LePatner warns that we could see a raft of partially completed projects going idle as contractors fold.

Trying to stretch an unfeasible budget might also lead to poor workmanship and understaffing–problematic on multiple fronts in a country trying to fix its infrastructure and boost employment.

Why would a firm underbid? It’s a question LePatner explores in his book Broken Buildings, Busted Budgets (U. of Chicago). The industry is dysfunctional and “anti-competitive” in many respects, he argues, and there can sometimes be business advantages in making impossibly low bids.

But many stimulus projects are “fixed price” contracts, meaning that firms will have less leeway in finding ways to eventually eke out a profit.

“We want our construction industry to make a fair profit,” LePatner says. “I’m waiting to see if they can pull this off in some novel way.”

America’s First Infrastructure Stimulus Project: A Bridge to Nowhere?

Wednesday, February 18th, 2009

osage-bridge
Missouri was really eager to get bragging rights on this whole “shovel-ready” thing. The governor and various other officials, including state transportation director Pete Rahn, staked out a rural bridge yesterday while Obama prepared to sign the stimulus bill. As soon as the presidential nib came up from the page, the $8.5 million project to replace the Route 17 bridge over the Osage River near Tuscumbia was officially underway. The state tendered a check for slightly over $200,000 to the contractor on the project and a backhoe immediately started digging a hole for a pylon.

According to Rahn, the firm was about to lay off a employees and the stimulus allowed them to hire instead. “There were a lot of happy construction workers,” he said later. He expects the project will create a total of 250 jobs.

Of course, it’s also worth noting that the bridge is not exactly a crucial artery – it serves a town of about 200 people and, according to local paper, is “so remote that Missouri transportation officials brought a special satellite truck to allow highway commissioners to meet and award the bridge construction contract.” We don’t know exactly what that means, but it does sound pretty remote.